Eunomia's 60% recycling limit claim not true

Eunomia has today published the latest version of its residual waste review. This has generated headlines on the basis that England's local authorities are going to build so much capacity that they will effectively place an upper limit on their recycling rates of 60%.

Eunomia makes this claim on the basis that England will build roughly 5 million more tonnes of capacity on top of the current 5.5 million tonnes, thereby only leaving only 15.5 million tonnes available for recycling. But this is of course a partial analysis which is only looking at residual LA waste (taking their figures at face value). England also generates much larger quantities of residual commercial waste which also needs to find a home.

Eunomia's report/media line talks about local authorities tying themselves down with the minimum tonnages which they are committing to the facilities in the pipeline. But minimum tonnages in residual waste contracts consist not only of Contract Waste from the Authority, but Substitute Waste from commercial sources as well.

In other words, as levels of local authority residual waste fall during the life of a contract, the shortfall is made up using commercial sources, i.e. more and more residual commercial waste is used during the life of the contract so that the plant can keep running while the authority remains incentivised to meet its recycling commitments elsewhere.

To say that England's authorities are therefore constraining their recycling rates to 60% is nonsense.